Selects wrong reciepient when replying to all.

[bugs.virtualidentity@…]

I was on the old stable version (0.5.14), I've just upgraded to the latest (0.6.1) to try and sort this.

When I "reply to all" in an email where I'm in the "to" header, but not the "cc" headers, virtual identity seems to choose the first entry in the "cc" headers, not the "to". Thus, it sets someone else as my from address.

[bugs.virtualidentity@…]

Debug log of clicking reply to all (emails sanitised for public web)

[bugs.virtualidentity@…]

Sanitised raw message headers for the problematic message

[anonymous]

Replying to bugs.virtualidentity@…:

I was on the old stable version (0.5.14), I've just upgraded to the latest (0.6.1) to try and sort this.

When I "reply to all" in an email where I'm in the "to" header, but not the "cc" headers, virtual identity seems to choose the first entry in the "cc" headers, not the "to". Thus, it sets someone else as my from address.

Ack. Apologies, got this wrong. The actual problem is that it's using the "from" field (incorrectly), even though I'm in the "to" field.

[rene]

Hi,

the problem is indicated in

## vI_smartIdentity: reply on non-received (sent?) mail. Using SmartDraft. 

for whatever reason the received-header of the mail you make the reply to are not detected. Therefore Virtual Identity assumes you are editing a draft - which is actually wrong.

Please post the debug-log if you select the message in the main 3-pane-window. There should be a line like "found header received ...stored to recognize received mail" - and probably the is no line like this. Additionally check the Error Console for related errors.

Thanks, nice regards, Rene

[bugs.virtualidentity@…]

Hi Rene, thanks for looking at this.

I don't get anything appearing in the debug window when I select the message with my current version of virtual identity (I think the old version did put messages there...but I can't remember).

All I have after restarting Thunderbird and then clicking around several messages in my inbox is:

Thunderbird 3.0.1 (20100111101938; Windows NT 5.1)
 - AutoMsgSelect Extension {33f5deda-7390-491f-b15b-8f3fe0882b1d} 0.1.2
 - British English Dictionary en-GB@dictionaries.addons.mozilla.org 1.19
 - DictionarySearch {a0faa0a4-f1a7-4098-9a74-21efc3a92372} 3.6.2
 - Display mail route {F8147CF4-B9E3-445B-AA87-081ED66548FB} 0.3.1
 - Display Mail User Agent {F8147CF4-B9E3-445B-AA87-081ED66548F8} 1.6.5
 - Display mailing list header {F8147CF4-B9E3-445B-AA87-081ED66548F9} 0.3.2
 - Display Quota {c1ac4523-76c2-9995-adbd-d93bf5141bea} 0.3.1
 - Duplicate Contact Manager {b4447f60-db9c-11da-a94d-0800200c9a66} 0.6
 - Enigmail {847b3a00-7ab1-11d4-8f02-006008948af5} 1.0.1
 - Image Zoom {1A2D0EC4-75F5-4c91-89C4-3656F6E44B68} 0.4.4
 - MinimizeToTray {31513E58-F253-47ad-86DB-D5F21E905429} 0.0.1.2006102615+ [DISABLED]
 - Nightly Tester Tools {8620c15f-30dc-4dba-a131-7c5d20cf4a29} 2.0.3
 - Quote Colors {B274D460-4DF9-454c-AC69-CA71398D7498} 0.3
 - Sender Verification Extension {ff7e40e0-08b4-11d9-9669-0800200c9a66} 0.9.0.2
 - Sync On Arrival {304fe8a0-ad69-442a-9fe6-4226a073ae6a} 1.3
 - Thunderbird Address Book Synchronisation Extension {CCB7D94B-CA92-4E3F-B79D-ADE0F07ADC74} 7.3.1.68
 - Update Notifier {95f24680-9e31-11da-a746-0800200c9a66} 0.1.5.5
 - Virtual Identity {dddd428e-5ac8-4a81-9f78-276c734f75b8} 0.6.1
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
## vI_rdfDatasource read rdf from 'file:///H:/.WinShared/Application%20Data/Thunderbird/Profiles/99v6p8f1.default/virtualIdentity.rdf'
## vI_account: checking for leftover VirtualIdentity accounts  - done
## vI_account: checking for leftover VirtualIdentity directories  - done

I just clicked reply on this email and it too shows the same problem.

If I disable smart draft it behaves correctly, so I'll do that as I don't use the feature (intentionally ;))

[rene]

Hi,

good that you found some workaround.

Anyway, the problem might bug some other users, therefore it will be nice to get it fixed. And there should be some debug-output once you select a message in the 3pane-window. Can you please do this and check the error-console (see tools menu) for related javascript errors? Probably something is broken in the extension...

Nice regards, Rene

[bugs.virtualidentity@…]

Ok, it wasn't showing messages before, but it is now, so here you are:

Thunderbird 3.0.3 (20100227143138; Windows NT 5.1)
 - AutoMsgSelect Extension {33f5deda-7390-491f-b15b-8f3fe0882b1d} 0.1.2 [DISABLED]
 - British English Dictionary en-GB@dictionaries.addons.mozilla.org 1.19
 - DictionarySearch {a0faa0a4-f1a7-4098-9a74-21efc3a92372} 3.6.2
 - Display mail route {F8147CF4-B9E3-445B-AA87-081ED66548FB} 0.3.1
 - Display Mail User Agent {F8147CF4-B9E3-445B-AA87-081ED66548F8} 1.6.5
 - Display mailing list header {F8147CF4-B9E3-445B-AA87-081ED66548F9} 0.3.2 [DISABLED]
 - Display Quota {c1ac4523-76c2-9995-adbd-d93bf5141bea} 0.3.1
 - Duplicate Contact Manager {b4447f60-db9c-11da-a94d-0800200c9a66} 0.6 [DISABLED]
 - Enigmail {847b3a00-7ab1-11d4-8f02-006008948af5} 1.0.1
 - Image Zoom {1A2D0EC4-75F5-4c91-89C4-3656F6E44B68} 0.4.4
 - MinimizeToTray {31513E58-F253-47ad-86DB-D5F21E905429} 0.0.1.2006102615+ [DISABLED]
 - Nightly Tester Tools {8620c15f-30dc-4dba-a131-7c5d20cf4a29} 2.0.3
 - Quote Colors {B274D460-4DF9-454c-AC69-CA71398D7498} 0.3
 - Sender Verification Extension {ff7e40e0-08b4-11d9-9669-0800200c9a66} 0.9.0.2 [DISABLED]
 - Sync On Arrival {304fe8a0-ad69-442a-9fe6-4226a073ae6a} 1.3 [DISABLED]
 - Thunderbird Address Book Synchronisation Extension {CCB7D94B-CA92-4E3F-B79D-ADE0F07ADC74} 7.3.1.68
 - Update Notifier {95f24680-9e31-11da-a746-0800200c9a66} 0.1.5.5
 - Virtual Identity {dddd428e-5ac8-4a81-9f78-276c734f75b8} 0.6.4
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
## vI_getHeader: found header: received  ...stored to recognize received mail
## vI_getHeader: found header: to[:1] - stored as '<c@h.com>,
	<m@h.com>,
	<s@i.com>,
	<m@j.co.uk>'
## vI_getHeader: found header: cc[:1] - stored as '<h@j.co.uk>'

[rene]

Hi,

thats magic :) now that you get

## vI_getHeader: found header: received  ...stored to recognize received mail

if you select any email, are you in the compose-dialog still getting

## vI_smartIdentity: reply on non-received (sent?) mail. Using SmartDraft. 

if you do a reply on it? (enable SmartDraft? for a test)

Nice regards, Rene

[rene]

closing ticket, please reopen and reply if problem still exists